How-To Guides

How to Analyze Competitor Backlinks: What Actually Works

By BacklinkPrice Team · Nov 18, 2026 · Updated Nov 20, 2026 · 12 min read
Illustrated cover for How to Analyze Competitor Backlinks

To analyze competitor backlinks, compare 3 to 5 rivals in a backlink tool, find sites that link to them but not to you, and sort those prospects by relevance and traffic.

To analyze competitor backlinks, enter 3 to 5 rival domains in a backlink tool, export their referring domains, and sort the list by relevance, traffic, and link type before you act on it. The goal is a short list of sites that already link to similar pages, not a count of every link a rival has.

Key takeaways

  • Pick 3 to 5 real rivals that rank for your target keywords, not the largest brands in your niche.
  • A link gap is a site that links to your rivals but not to you, and it is the fastest place to find new prospects.
  • Judge each prospect by relevance, real traffic, and link type, not by one authority score alone.
  • Broken pages and wrong redirects on rival sites are direct chances to offer a working replacement page.
  • Buying links for rankings is link spam under Google's rules, so pursue earned links and qualify paid links correctly.
  • Repeat the check each month and track new referring domains, not total backlink counts.

Competitor backlink analysis is the study of which sites link to your rivals, which pages they link to, and what anchor text they use.

It turns a rival's link profile into a prospect list for your own site. You compare your profile with theirs, find the gaps, and check which gaps you can close with a better page or a fair pitch.

A link profile is the full set of links pointing to a site, so this work is a comparison of profiles, not a look at one link in isolation.

It matters because backlinks still track closely with rankings, and your rivals show you which links are already working in your niche.

Semrush found in its 2024 Ranking Factors study that 8 of the top 20 factors with the strongest link to ranking were related to backlinks.

The same Semrush study found that the median number of backlinks for top-ranking pages was only 13, so a small set of good links can be enough.

Ahrefs found in its 2023 study of about 14 billion pages that 96.55% of pages get zero traffic from Google, while 1.94% get between 1 and 10 monthly visits.

That study also found that only 2,997 of about 20 million pages with no referring domains get more than 1,000 search visits per month.

The pattern is clear: pages with no sites linking to them rarely get found, and rivals that rank often have links you do not have yet.

Comparing backlinks with referring domains helps here, because one domain can send many links, and new domains matter more than repeat links from the same site.

Follow these steps in order, and save your export at each step so you can repeat the check later.

Step 1: Pick 3 to 5 real rivals

Pick rivals that rank for the keywords you want, sell to the same buyers, and are close to your size.

Ahrefs says to enter your site in Site Explorer and open the Organic competitors report, which lists sites that rank for the same keywords as your target.

Skip a giant brand that wins links from press coverage you cannot match. A rival one step ahead of you gives you prospects you can reach in weeks, not years.

Enter one rival domain in your tool and open its backlinks report, then export the full list with referring domain, target page, anchor text, and link type.

Ahrefs says its free backlink checker shows the total backlinks and referring domains plus the top 100 backlinks, with referring page, anchor, and target URL.

For a full export, use a paid tool. Ahrefs says to plug a rival domain into Site Explorer and open the Backlinks report, where one example in its guide showed over 80,000 backlinks.

If you want a second view, check backlinks for any website with the same steps and compare the two lists before you trust either one alone.

A link gap check finds sites that link to your rivals but not to you, and it is the core step in this whole process.

In Ahrefs, open Link Intersect, enter your homepage, add a few rival homepages, set the search mode to "URL", and click "Show link opportunities".

Semrush offers the same idea in its Backlink Gap tool, which compares up to 5 competing websites at once and lists the referring domains that link to them.

Use the "Best" tab in that tool, which shows domains that point to all of your rivals but not to you, since those sites already link to more than one site like yours.

Sort the gap list before you contact anyone, because most rows will be low value, off topic, or hard to win.

Start with dofollow links from pages that are on topic for your page, then check whether the linking page gets real traffic and still links to live pages.

Anchor text is the clickable text of a link, so read it to see how each site describes your rival and whether that wording fits your page too.

Semrush reviewed the top 100 websites in its rank list in June 2025 and found that, on average, 71% of their backlinks were follow links and 29% were nofollow links.

A healthy profile has both types, so do not delete nofollow prospects from your list, but put follow links from relevant pages first.

Step 5: Find each rival's best linked pages

Open the Best by links report for each rival and note which pages earn the most links, because those pages show what your niche rewards.

A guide, a free tool, a data page, or an original study often earns more links than a product page, and that tells you what to build next.

Step 6: Look for broken pages and bad redirects

Broken pages and bad redirects are links you can win by offering a working page, and they are easy to spot in the same reports.

In Ahrefs, open Best by links for a rival, add a "404 not found" filter, and you will see dead pages sorted by the number of referring domains that point to them.

Ahrefs gives one example of a dead page about SEO tips that still had backlinks from 177 referring domains, which is a large pool of sites to contact.

For redirects, add a "3XX redirect" filter instead. Ahrefs gives an example of a Search Engine Land page that had backlinks from 1.2K referring domains but redirected to an unrelated page.

Use the Wayback Machine to see what the dead page used to say, then build a page that covers the same topic well before you ask anyone to change a link.

Look at the tactics behind the links, because a tactic that works for a rival can work for you even if the exact link cannot be copied.

Guest posting is the third most popular link building tactic, according to Aira's 2022 State of Link Building report, as cited by Ahrefs.

To find a rival's guest posts, search Content Explorer for a topic plus author:"name of your rival's prolific marketer" and filter for one page per domain.

For interviews and podcasts, filter the Backlinks report for referring page URLs that contain "podcast", "episode", or "interview", then pitch the same shows with a clear topic.

Tools, time and cost

Use one paid backlink tool as your main source, plus a free checker for a second view, and keep the same tool for repeat checks so your numbers stay comparable.

Semrush says its Backlinks tool draws on a database of more than 43 trillion links, and its Backlink Gap limits run from 3,000 requests per day on its Pro plan to 10,000 per day on its Business plan.

Ahrefs lists its plans as of November 2026 at Starter $29 per month, Lite $129 per month, Standard $249 per month, Advanced $449 per month, and Enterprise at custom pricing.

The Lite plan at $129 per month includes 1,000 credits per month, 6 months of historical data, and 750 tracked keywords in Rank Tracker, as of November 2026.

ToolWhat it showsBest use
Ahrefs Site ExplorerBacklinks, referring domains, anchors, and link gapsMain rival check and Link Intersect
Semrush Backlink GapDomains that link to rivals but not to youGap list for up to 5 sites at once
Google Search ConsoleYour own top linked pages and linking sitesBaseline for your own profile
Bing Webmaster ToolsYour links plus up to 2 rival sitesFree second view of gaps
Moz Link ExplorerDomain Authority, Page Authority, and Spam ScoreQuick authority check on prospects
Majestic Site ExplorerTrust Flow and Citation Flow for a domainQuality check on link prospects

Judge a prospect by relevance first, then by traffic and link type, and use authority scores only as a rough filter.

Domain Authority is a Moz score from 1 to 100 that predicts how likely a website is to rank compared with competitors, according to Shopify in 2026.

There is no universal good score, since a score only means something when you compare it with the rivals that rank for your target keywords.

Ahrefs published an analysis in June 2026 that found the top 10 organic results for "best running shoes" had an average Domain Rating of 76, while the lowest score among them was 29.

Domain Rating is Ahrefs' own score, so use the same tool for every rival and every prospect, or your numbers will not compare.

Majestic's Trust Flow is a 0 to 100 score for link quality, and its Citation Flow is a separate 0 to 100 score for link quantity, according to ToolsBattle in November 2026.

The Trust Ratio is Trust Flow divided by Citation Flow, and ToolsBattle says ratios far below 0.3 often point to a profile heavy on low-quality links.

A page with Trust Flow 30 and Citation Flow 60, for example, has many links but lower relative quality, so read the linking pages before you trust the score.

Work the gap list in small groups, and match each prospect with a page on your site that deserves the link.

Listicles are a good start. Search Content Explorer for "competitor 1" "competitor 2" "competitor 3" -"your business name" to find lists that mention rivals but not you.

Broken backlinks are the clearest win, because the linking site already wanted to link to that topic and its old link no longer works.

For each broken target, confirm the old page topic, build or improve your replacement page, then send a short note that names the dead link and offers your page as a fix.

How to measure results

Measure new referring domains each month, not total backlinks, because one new domain is a stronger sign than 20 new links from a site that already links to you.

Set a baseline on the day you run the gap check, with counts for your site and for each rival, and save the export with the date in the file name.

Track which gap prospects you contacted, which ones replied, and which ones added a link, so you can see which type of prospect converts best.

Find backlink opportunities on a regular cycle, and re-run the gap check after you publish a new linkable page, since a fresh page can change which sites are worth contacting.

Watch for lost links too. Semrush says its Backlinks tool has a "Lost and Vital" list for high-priority links you used to have, and you can ask the site owner to restore a link that broke during a redesign.

Common mistakes

  • Copying a rival's whole link list without sorting it first, which wastes outreach on directories, forums, and off-topic pages that will not help you.
  • Picking rivals that are far larger than you, then chasing press links and brand mentions that a small site cannot win in the short term.
  • Trusting one authority score as proof of value, while skipping the linking page, its topic, and whether it gets real traffic.
  • Buying links to close a gap fast, which Google lists as link spam when the links are bought for ranking purposes.
  • Running the check once and never repeating it, which leaves new rival links and lost links unseen for months.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many competitors should I analyze?

Analyze 3 to 5 rivals that rank for your target keywords and serve the same buyers. Fewer than 3 gives you a thin gap list, while more than 5 adds noise and makes sorting slow. Pick rivals close to your size first, then add one stronger rival only to see what the next level of links looks like.

Yes, you can start for free with a limited view. Ahrefs says its free backlink checker shows the top 100 backlinks for a domain, and Google Search Console shows your own links at no cost. A paid plan is needed for full exports, filters, and gap reports across several rivals.

A backlink gap is a set of sites that link to your rivals but not to you. Tools find it by comparing referring domains across several domains at once. The "Best" tab in Semrush Backlink Gap shows domains that link to all of your rivals but not to you, and those are often the most willing prospects.

Repeat the check once a month for most sites, and sooner after you publish a major new page or a rival launches a large campaign. Monthly checks catch new links, lost links, and fresh broken pages while the list is still small enough to sort by hand.

No, you should not copy every link, because many rival links are hard to win, off topic, or low value. Sort by relevance, traffic, and link type first, then pursue directories, listicles, broken links, and bad redirects that fit your page. Skip links that come from paid placements or sites that do not fit your topic.

Yes, they can matter for traffic and awareness, even though they pass less ranking value than follow links. Semrush found in June 2025 that 71% of backlinks for the top 100 sites in its rank list were follow links and 29% were nofollow links. Keep nofollow prospects on your list, but put relevant follow links first.

Sources

If you want to compare what a link costs once you know which sites to target, see our pricing page.

BacklinkPrice Team
Written by
BacklinkPrice Team
Link building and backlink pricing research

The BacklinkPrice Team researches backlink prices, publisher sites and link building tools. We check prices and plans against each provider's own pages and date them, so you know how current the numbers are.

More from BacklinkPrice Team

Related guides